Adam Kinney on .NET

Hunting Godzilla in .NET...

A Managed Open Source Project == Oxymoron?

Last week, Scott Mitchell posted an entry referencing difficulties when managing an open source project.  So that got me thinking about the whole situation.  I'm wondering if most microsofties here on weblogs.asp.net, have taken part in an open source project, before GotDotNet Workspaces.  The most mature .NET one I learned about before then was SharpVectorGraphics, lead by DonXML.

Based on this thought stream and an imminent bowl of Fruit Loops, I have three questions:

1)  I wonder why there are not more project managers in training/college not involved in Open Source Projects.  It seems like some real world experience they could gain and if done well could properly organize a project and move it along towards a complete version.  This person wouldn't be there to code, just to handle the tasks of organizing and communicating.  Maybe the Open Source Movement doesn't lend itself to organization?  Or people are there for fun or casual coding and don't wish to follow assignments(orders)?

2)  Now that there is the new wave of Microsoft aiding open source development, who is actively involved in an Open Source Project?  Not one where you fit into the Creator role, but one where have you joined after the initial push and have been able to contribute a significant amount.

3)  Easy one last; in your opinion, what's the best project to come out of GDN Workspaces?

Disclaimer:  I am new to the whole Open Source thing myself, so feel free to “school” me, if you have greater depth in experience than me.

Comments

Chris Stewart said:

1. Being a college student myself, I find it safe to say most of us do not have enough time to do much outside of school. At least not enough to give an honest effort.

2. I'm not seeing a question...

3. Easy, .Text. :-)
# November 16, 2003 9:27 PM

Jeff Julian said:

It is very hard to manage a Workspace. To get people working, the admins have to do most of the grunt work. It is much more painful then a paid project.

3. LearningXml.com will be the best project, but for now, RSSBandit in my book.
# November 16, 2003 11:04 PM

Adam Kinney said:


Chris & Jeff:

Re: 1) True the time thing is a big factor, but who has time for night time open source projects. Maybe some single guy living off a fat trust fund or just someone who really wants to project to come to existence.

Re: 2) I added the question mark I forgot in #2, first sentence.

Re: 3) .Text is like you said an awesome application, but I believe that most of it is the work of ScottW. I am looking for one where the work is more evenly distributed. Maybe Jeff's claim about LearningXml.com will be the example I am looking for.
# November 17, 2003 8:50 AM
Leave a Comment

(required) 

(required) 

(optional)

(required)