.Text blog commenting has a problem. Identity Theft.
For the past couple days, there's been this ongoing thing where Frans Bouma has been calling Microsoft evil for having some hidden, dark agenda behind eliciting feedback thru their blogs, and calling any developers that do give feedback, naive for thinking that they could possible make a difference to the borg product.
Whatever... That's not the point of this post. That's just the backstory.
The point is that one of the reasons that Frans gave for disabling the controversial posts is that annoying people who were sufficiently angry about his insinuations, were using his name in comments, pretending to be him, and generally being jerks.
For at least a decade, lots of really smart people have been claiming that Identity Theft is going to be the Next Big Problem, and I've always agreed with it. These days you can see the general populace becoming more aware of it, mostly thru ad campaigns coming from banks and credit card companies. The most obvious of which are the recent hilarious tv commercials where you have some victim of identity theft talking to the camera in the voice of the person who stole their money and went on a crime shopping spree.
But to get back to .Text...
The commenting system on blogs doesn't require you to register in order to enter a comment, which I think is a good thing. Some people may argue against it, and they do have some valid points, but overall, I think anonymous commenting has an effect of increasing community inolvement. However, the commenting system also doesn't allow you to login either. There is no way for anybody to verify or check to see if the “Andy Smith” who just commented on their blog is actually me, or maybe some other Andy ( there's a lot of us Andy Smith's in the world... last time I checked, there were 4 just in my town ), or maybe just some jerk pretending to be me for comedic effect.
At any rate... what's the answer? Passport? public key signing of comments? I don't know. “I am who I say I am” is a tough problem.