Sometimes, DSL sucks!

Posted Thursday, June 19, 2003 7:35 AM by G Andrew Duthie

After having gone through a complete DSL outage described here, my ISP was able to get the line back up in a couple of days. Unfortunately, since the line came back up (apparently my local telco had either cut or disconnected the line about a mile away from my house), it's been bouncing (dropping and reconnecting) erratically. This has been going on for days, and my ISP doesn't seem to have done a whole lot about it. Now the line is completely dead. So I called them up today, and got a nice person on the phone who asked me to disconnect and reconnect the line, and then to power-cycle the router (for only the bazillionth time), just like every other time I've called. Then they got Covad on the phone, and had me do yet another cycle of disconnect/reconnect/power-cycle.

After all that, the answer is that they'll send a Covad tech out to test the router, the inside wiring, and the NID (Network Interface Device - i.e. - the box on the back or side of your house where the phone lines come in). Now I guess I should be happy that an actual physical person will be working on the problem, but it strikes me as funny that in order to solve a problem that started with a break in the line more than a mile from my house, they're going to send someone to test stuff in my house! One kind of has to wonder who's training these people in troubleshooting.

Alas, by the time I post this, the problem will presumably be solved (if only temporarily [UPDATE - the line's back up, though not yet "fixed"]), since while I write this I have no Internet connectivity other than my cell phone (and thank goodness for that, at lesast I can still get my email. This kind of thing makes me wonder whether perhaps I should look into whether I can get a T1 (or a fractional T1) installed here. I've tried cable, but they don't allow servers, and the upload speed stinks. SDSL is pretty good in terms of speed, but the reliability has sometimes been considerably worse than cable (which is saying something). There's got to be a better way.

Seems to me that if services that rely on broadband are ever going to take off, the broadband industry is going to have to get much better. Based on more than two years' experience with cable and DSL, things seem to be getting worse, not better. OTOH, I could just be really peeved at the moment, and not seeing as clearly as I might.

Comments

# re: Sometimes, DSL sucks!

Thursday, June 19, 2003 12:46 PM by Rob Zelt

Andrew, if it makes you feel any better, I once had a DSL connection go down where I proved with the Telco tech support that there was an address mapping error on my DSL port that let me go nowhere. However to correct this issue, even though we knew what the problem was a tech needed to be dispatched on site, who then could call into the appropriate area to have the problem corrected within minutes, expcept it would be 4 days before a tech could be dispatched to my place to make the phone call.

# re: Sometimes, DSL sucks!

Friday, June 20, 2003 10:44 AM by Kamran

I heard Sattelite is faster than T1, according to a friend of my grandpa's. And it's cheaper in the long run too...you can get it by using DirectTV (it's BY that company, but its something different)

Look it to it. They offer it for $60 a month and a $550 installation.

# re: Sometimes, DSL sucks!

Thursday, February 05, 2004 3:40 AM by Mike

Yeah but if you are an online gamer than the satelite sucks cause it has a 1 or 2 second delay in upload.

# re: Sometimes, DSL sucks!

Tuesday, February 17, 2004 9:01 PM by Bob

why is my dsl so crappy the total speed when i download software of the internet is about 120KB/Sec
and i pay 50 bucks, is it not supposed to be like 400KB/sec anyway if this is the true speed then i must say it sucks ass.

# re: Sometimes, DSL sucks!

Tuesday, June 15, 2004 4:07 AM by Alex

When you're downloading software it's really slow? Well, how many downloads are you running at once? Do you have file sharing software on your computer?
Try rebooting your PC, unplugging all the cables in the back of the modem for about 5-10s then plugging them back in and then reboot the PC. When your computer starts up don't open any programs or any file sharing software if you have any, in fact close everything, all you want is to be connected and have the Internet Explorer up. Then go to http://infospeed.verizon.net and run a test, see what you get.
Obviously if you're downloading from someone with dial-up it's going to be extremley slow OR if you're downloading from someone who has hi-speed however he's using a lot of his upstream then you're not going to get a great download speed either, there are many factors to put into place.

# re: Sometimes, DSL sucks!

Friday, February 05, 2010 5:46 AM by Install Software

Another great post.

Thanks for the tips and help.

Everyone, bookmark this site.

Leave a Comment

(required) 
(required) 
(optional)
(required)