Jeff and .NET

The .NET musings of Jeff Putz

Sponsors

News

My Sites

Archives

Community development and getting questions answered

Josh Ledgard made a brilliant post where he took inventory of the issues surrounding the Microsoft community. I'm glad to see this because I think we're at a critical point in the .NET world where we're hitting critical mass and we need more qualified people to work. People get qualified by working in community, in my opinion. Josh's observations need to be looked at, so that we don't end up with another “look at me” Channel9 thing (days later, I'm still not impressed, but they also had a save the world hype to live up to).

Two generalizations hit me as most relevant. The first is that too much volume is bad. I think when you run or lead a community you frequently forget that, but it's not a contest. The ASP.NET forums have almost too much volume, unfortunately. I would be curious to know, however, what percentage of visitors there post or just read. I know from my experience at CoasterBuzz, which is just social and not technical, that not all 10,000 daily visitors are posting. It probably isn't more than a hundred.

The other thing that stands out is that, the way Josh sees it, there should be some kind of better medium that is a cross between Web forums and Usenet. I personally have never liked Usenet much, at least not since the proliferation of Web forums, but there are some obvious aspects of the two that could be combined into a better product. That's stuff I think about a lot, but my disregard for Usenet has kind of prevented me from seeing that.

One other thing I guess is that online communities, regardless of the topic, need to breed a culture or protocol where people do actually search for an answer before asking the question. You'd think that since people land in these communities from a search engine that searching them would be obvious, but I know in practice that it's obviously not!

Posted: Apr 15 2004, 10:54 AM by Jeff | with 3 comment(s)
Filed under:

Comments

Scott Galloway said:

Very interesting, the ASP.NET forums (where I've been lurking of late) certainly suffer from many of these issues, the "TOP" rating is badly abused - put simply it rewards useless posting (the number of 'I agree' posts over there is getting nuts). The search functions over there too are pretty nasty - one biggy, try putting in a search term and hitting 'Enter' - unexpected isn't it!. Try doing that inside a forum, that generates an error page the vast majority of the time. That said though there is a lot of good information over there and if people just spent two minutes trying to use the search, a good 80% of the posts could be avoided. It has a FAQ forum (IMHO this should be a post at the top of each forum, most of them have between 20-30 recurrent questions, answering them in one place would again stop redundancy).
# April 15, 2004 11:19 AM

Jeff said:

Don't even get me started about "top" members. That's the single most useless "feature" any forum has ever had. It doesn't do anything to facilitate discussion. Does anyone remember discussion? :)
# April 15, 2004 12:40 PM

jledgard said:

Thanks for your feedback. I'll be interested in reading what you think about my proposed solutions.
# April 15, 2004 12:56 PM
Leave a Comment

(required) 

(required) 

(optional)

(required)