Mike Bosch's Blog on .NET

Agile enterprise architecture in .NET, SOA, WCF, WS-*, AJAX, MVC, Sharepoint and more...

August 2007 - Posts

Application Definition files for Sharepoint 2007

I finally got around to playing with the new Business Data Catalog service in Sharepoint 2007.  I've always thought that Sharepoint was a great tool for "putting a face" to an enterprise's SOA effort, and this gets it one step closer.   The process involves creating a LobSystem(line-of-business system).  This involves creating what is known as an "Application Definition" file.  This file describes your LobSystem(entities, methods, actions etc). 

You can easily use a web service as the source for this.  However, the XML for this file is quite verbose.  Eager to start creating my own LobSystems, I ran across BDC Meta Man.  This is a great tool that lets you create Application Definition files though a (decent) GUI. 

Check it out below:


Video: BDC Meta Man Getting Started
Posted: Aug 15 2007, 03:50 PM by MikeBosch | with 1 comment(s) |
Filed under:
SOA is not about technology

I've been involved in recent discussions on the divide between architecture and technology.  I think many developers often confuse an implementation technology with architecture.  I believe there is an important distinction between the two.  This is often exemplified in some people's definition of SOA as "web services".  Apparently, if you can code a web service, you are officially a service oriented architecture guru.  I was reading an e-book I found on MSDN's Architecture site and thought it provided a good metaphor depicting how important it is to have an architecture blueprint and know the difference between architecture vs. technology.  At the risk of duplicated content on the web, here it is and the book can be downloaded here:

"The Winchester Mystery House is an intriguing tourist attraction in the USA near San Jose, CA. The Winchester Mystery House was the home to the heiress of the Winchester fortune (amassed from the sales of Winchester rifles). According to the legend, the heiress went to see a fortune teller and learned she was cursed to be haunted by the spirits of everyone ever killed by a Winchester rifle. The only way to avoid the curse was to build a mansion – as long as she kept building the spirits would leave her alone. She promptly hired 147 builders (and 0 architects), all of whom began working on the mansion simultaneously. The builders worked on the mansion until the heiress passed away, 38 years later. The result of their efforts is a classic example of implementation without architecture:

  • The mansion contains 160 rooms, 40 bedrooms, 6 kitchens, 2 basements and 950 doors
  • Of there 950 doors, 65 of them open to blank walls, 13 staircases were built and abandoned and 24 skylights were installed into various floors.
  • No architectural blueprint for the mansion was ever created.

Confusing architecture with implementation generates chaotic and unpredictable results – much like the Winchester Mystery House. Articles that try to explain SOA and jump into a tutorial for building Web Services are providing guidance for coding, not architecture. This is one of the many reasons that SOA is so misunderstood today – the rush to promote loosely coupled architectures focuses on the trees instead of the forest. "

More Posts