Rob Chartier ~ Contemplation...

.NET, C#, Work, etc.

News

www.flickr.com
This is a Flickr badge showing public photos from Rob & Kat Chartier. Make your own badge here.


Website Counter

Even Quicker Links

Ceedo, its not worth it just yet.

I managed to take a deeper look at the Ceedo product which I previously posted on. They have a pretty decent story about wrapping up the application -the whole “Application” or “OS” virtualization thing. From what I can tell it simply monitors all calls to the registry and the the local file system (My Documents, etc.) and re-routes them to the virtualized versions of each. This is one of the bigger pain points of running any application from a portable device; its nice to see them try to solve that. Note that you can still find hundreds of applications which do not rely on either the registry or well known windows paths.

Other than their virtualization technology I dont really see much value to their offering. They have a fancy menu which hides in the system tray if you tell it too, but you can get that for free.

It would be nice to see them produce their virtualization product as a standalone wrapper around other applications. Reg Rapper somewhat solves the whole wrapper around the registry, which does a ½ decent job at it; and its free but I dont see it handling file system calls – not that this is all that important either way.

Mirror 

Comments

CodeSniper said:

I received Ceedo with my Lexar Lightning Drive a while back and thought it looked cool.  But after trying to use it for a few weeks, I stopped using it altogether in favor of the simpler PStart.exe menu.

Ceedo was just too mouse-centric for me.  I love me some hotkeys and never could quite get Ceedo to behave as I desired.

At this point, there are too many sites like PortableApps.com that offer lightweight, portable-attuned versions of most popular applications.

Also, I think the U3 platform is the real future for more complex portable apps that need the registry and other infrastructure that Ceedo provides.

# January 15, 2007 7:08 PM

NotCeedoEmployee said:

Did you forget that Ceedo also virtualizes the entire windows user directories?

Without using Argo I have been able to make many apps install and work within Ceedo, without installing a single file on the host platform. You can wait till Reg Rapper does that. I am sticking with Ceedo.

# January 9, 2008 4:32 AM

Tom Bombadil said:

I think this document is a little old (January 2007!) I don't know how it got to be 4th place when I search Google for Ceedo

# March 7, 2008 10:32 AM

biill zhang said:

I'm a craze Flash Drive user and have several USB flash  drives with ceedo ,prayaya v3, mojopac,and l also  have a U3 smart drive .

I found each of them  have the advantages over the other. I have written a review about ceedo, u3, prayaya v3 and  mojopac.portable-applications.blog.com

# April 25, 2008 4:19 AM

russiakeys said:

try prayaya v3

# June 4, 2008 5:47 AM
Leave a Comment

(required) 

(required) 

(optional)

(required)