Ok so since posting about a System.Timers.Timer problem that I had quite a while ago on several newsgroups/mailing lists, I've received several emails asking about what the solution to the problem is/was so I decided it might be about time to let everyone in on it. Below is the basic email I've been sending out in reply to those messages...
I highly recommend that you switch to the System.Threading.Timer instead. Please read this thread, it has a couple of parts [0][1][2], it will give you great insight as to why the problem is occurring. Best of luck and I hope that helps. Regards, Sam [1]
I highly recommend that you switch to the System.Threading.Timer instead. Please read this thread, it has a couple of parts [0][1][2], it will give you great insight as to why the problem is occurring. Best of luck and I hope that helps. Regards, Sam
[1]
[2]
Thanks
hello ,
I have same problem.
any one can help me ???
I am having the same problem sam, can you please email me on grant.thomson@savante.co.uk
I have been writing a windows application using forms; have tried both system.timers.timer and forms.timer and both seem to fail.
Do you think going to threading.timer is the silver bullet here?
i have created a project and web service to it.... the service which is i created it use the exe file of the project. but service is not running..
Could some please explain how to switch from a system.windows.form.timer to a System.Threading.Timer
Sorry for posting again. I have been trawling the internet trying to find a meaningful example of System.Threading.Timer in plain english.
I am beginning to think that it doesn't.
I am trying to do something easy (so I thought). I want a service to write to a text file every minute in VB.net 2005, it doesn't appear possible.
If you could provide something simple to do this, I would be very grateful.
Nice one! Thanks a lot, this helped me out BIGTIME!
The funny thing is System.Timers.Timer uses System.Threading.Timer internally ( can be found through Reflector). So its a wrapper around Threading.Timer and microsoft tried to do some fancy things around the wrapper having some bugs in it. So its advised to use Threading.Timer.
There seems to be a similar problem with System.Windows.Forms.Timer not firing. I found if I called Stop() and Start() to frequently it would stop firing at all. Using System.Threading.Timer fixed the problem even though it is a forms based application
Hello all
I am using system.timer bt it is not working properly
So i have decided to switch to system.threading.timers
Please someone tell me how to switch from system.timer to system.threading.timer
By the way, I just wanted to point out that I was able to reproduce the dead timer issue on a VM server 2003 w/ SP1 which had .NET 2.0 Framework--it appears this issue is not isolated to JUST the 1.1 Framework
DDJames - To switch from system.timer to system.threading.timer; go into the Designer file and manually modify all instances of the times. So if the file that has the time is Service.vb, go to the Service.Designer.vb file and modify it. Hope that helps.
I am trying the examples posted on vbcity.com/.../topic.asp
private System.Timers.Timer MyTimer;
protected override void OnStart(string[] args)
{
// Interval in milliseconds
double interval = Properties.Settings.Default.TimeDelay * 60000;
// Create timer object
myTimer = new System.Timers.Timer(interval);
// Set to run more than once
timer.AutoReset = true;
// Delegate to handle the timer event
timer.Elapsed += new ElapsedEventHandler(timer_Elapsed);
// Start the timer
timer.Start();
// Prevents garbage collection from occuring in long running methods
GC.KeepAlive(timer);
}
private void timer_Elapsed(object sender, ElapsedEventArgs e)
try
myTimer.Stop();
// Place call here to execute code
finally
myTimer.Start();
He states that the timer stops running due to garbage collection and that every time the timer is stopped it is subjet to garbage collection. I don't know if this is the final solution but this is where I am with the process
This explains the issue
support.microsoft.com/.../842793
The URLs at the start of the post all appear to be dead. Please update them if possible.
Here's a great article that will help you understand Timers in Windows:
msdn.microsoft.com/.../cc164015.aspx