Attention: We are retiring the ASP.NET Community Blogs. Learn more >

Microsoft's anti-competitive behaviour

I think that people tend to focus on cash when they think of Microsoft - don't!  Focus instead on how innovation and marketing of computers can give you more time to do the important things in your life such as spend time with your family, excercise or make better informed dietary decisions.

Innovation to me means that when I take my new PC out of the box I can write notes, listen to music and connect to the Internet.  The fact that Microsoft sell a product (Windows X) with "bundled" ( an unusual term.  Think : pre-installed ) software which allows me to do this is probably the major reason that the personal PC market even exists in the scale that it does.

Something which interests me  - and that I'm not quite sure what criteria the EU used when they decided to focus on a media player - is why didn't they focus on the socket layer componentry or the simple text reader market instead?  Politics I suspect!  Or is it because they are second-guessing the future and concerned that gaining a monopoly in media devices will also give Microsoft a monopoly into even bigger delivery mechanism as media players stream off of the PC and onto broader delivery technologies - such as TV's and Phones?


Overall, if today's decision by the EU means that I get better access to cheaper/better/etc tools to run on my PC then I'm all for it.  My biggest concern however is that, by focussing solely on Microsoft's anti-competitive behaviour that I won't.  It's hard to see standards being lifted by bringing a major player down.  I think that, in addition to the the slap-on-the-wrist that the EU should also advise the consumer (Me) will manage to "discover" and get access to a better tool to do the job I might be lost.  They should also concentrate on ensuring that other significant players are doing their part to ensure that "mums and dads" have access to viable alternatives.

Should they have slapped Microsoft on the wrist?  Probably.  Should they slap other major players for failing to reach broader markets with their advertising dollars... most likely yes also.

6 Comments

  • You can take the "Is that legal integration?" past just sockets. You can take it to the GUI layer. At one point in time there was DOS, and Microsoft added a GUI layer and shipped it as an add-on. Eventually it combined both and shipped it as Windows 95. And it's not like there weren't other competing 3rd party GUIs (and non-GUIs that offered one of the new features of Windows: multitasking!). And there were even competing DOSes, although they had a small share of the market.



    So it leads to the obvious question: Would the competitive landscape been better off if Microsoft had been forced to continue selling DOS, while competing seperately on the GUI layer. What happened if a competing GUI layer beat Microsoft's and then decided to remove their dependency from DOS? Will, now no one is buying MS-DOS anymore. And what about the transition from DOS to NT? Would Microsoft have been required to ship a text-based NT OS that works seamlessly as the DOS version does with their Windows add-on? Or should Microsoft continue to offer DOS, but NT is a brand-new product obviously requiring a GUI?



    And its not like MS-DOS didn't have a significant share of the PC market. So if MS is a monopoly today, one might conclude MS was a monopoly around the time of Windows 95 being released. So it gives weight to the argument.



    Software's a strange beast when you start talking about integration and competition. Given enough development an individual software product could grow, and grow, and grow encompassing more and more functionality. It doesn't even have to be an operating system: Look at Emacs!

  • I don't mind having Media Player built in,

    but I would rather have none than have 3 (Media Player + Real + something else).



  • Undoubtfully nice story u have here. It'd be really cool to read more about this theme. Thanks for posting this information.

  • может у кого нить есть ещё информация по этому поводу??

  • I only just recently discovered the world of blogs, and I have to say you're quickly becoming one of my favorites. Great post and look forward to seeing more from you.

  • Это правда... что у людей с невысоким интллектом совсем нет... чувства юмора??
    новогодние открытки картинки плакаты

Comments have been disabled for this content.